Father Sam, who is well liked and content in his twilight years at Niagara Falls parish, receives a letter that turns his world upside down. The letter, from a past parishioner seeks the truth about an incident that happened 30 years ago. Father Sam was a young, charismatic priest in the North Bay parish. At that time the parishioner Christopher, was a 14 year-old boy he mentored. His letter asks Father Sam for the truth: did they have a sexual encounter that weekend at the cabin -- or was it all a dream?